Reprinted from the AAP
Highlight
News from the 2007 National Conference & Exhibition
Pediatric Practice
May Be Outmoded, Expert Says
Saying
that “the death of any child is a tragedy and the death
of any child from preventable causes is always unjust,”
Paul Wise, MD, MPH, FAAP, urged pediatricians attending
Friday’s Pediatrics for the 21st Century Symposium to
rethink pediatric practice in light of rapid changes
that are taking place in the epidemiology of childhood
disease and the impact of those changes on everyday
practice.
“Modern pediatrics has been characterized by remarkable
expansion in clinical capability,” said Dr Wise, the
Richard E. Behrman Professor of Child Health and
Society, and director of the Center for Policy Outcomes
and Prevention at Stanford University School of
Medicine.
“The development of a host of new vaccines, highly
effective antibiotics, medications for learning and
psychiatric disorders, and advances in intensive care
and pediatric surgery have all served to profoundly
enhance the capacity to provide pediatric services over
the past 50 years,” he began.
However, he expressed some concern about the future of
pediatric practice.
“Inherent in this record of remarkable success are the
seeds of obsolescence from transforming the threats to
child health so dramatically that the traditional
practice of pediatrics itself becomes increasingly
outmoded,” he said.
Dr Wise pointed to a dramatic reduction in acute
childhood diseases, and in particular infectious
diseases such as pneumoccocal disease, and a steady rise
in chronic conditions as major trends in child health
care.
“We’ve seen an evaporation of much of the traditional
acute infectious disease in this country. At the same
time, we’ve seen a slow but steady rise in the
prevalence of serious chronic conditions,” he said.
“Kids with genetic and neuro-developmental problems,
many of whom would have died 20 or 30 years ago, are now
surviving and going on to live happy lives, integrating
into school, family, and community life.”
He added that rates of asthma have gone up, as has the
prevalence of autism. Another chronic problem, obesity,
has become far more prevalent among children in America.
As a result, hospitals are taking care of more chronic
childhood diseases than acute diseases.
“These days, the likelihood that a well child is going
to get seriously ill, wind up hospitalized and go on to
die is extremely small, much smaller than it’s ever
been,” Dr Wise said. “The name of the game more than
ever before is serious chronic illness.”
“We are now increasingly expected in pediatrics to
confront what I would call precursor conditions to
adult-onset disease. Obesity is really a precursor
condition,” he said. “It sets kids up for a lifetime of
enhanced risk for a series of adult-onset diseases.”
One impact of these trends on pediatric practice is an
increased need for ongoing chronic disease management
for children. Another impact is the emergence of new
well-child care structures, such as retail-based
pediatric clinics that represent a challenge to
traditional pediatric theory and practice, Dr Wise said.
Other impacts on practice include the growth of the
specialty of hospitalists to address the increased
complexity of hospital care to treat chronic diseases
and the possibility that pediatricians will be less able
to take care of chronically ill children in the
hospital.
“Kids can be in an outpatient setting, wind up in an ER,
go to the ICU, back to the ward and back into primary
care practice within 36 hours. So the distinction
between outpatient, inpatient and ED care is becoming
increasingly blurred. That will put pressure on
pediatric practices and hospitals to be far more nimble
in their ability to confront complex problems,” Dr Wise.
“The last is what I think is the most troubling.
Pediatric practice is increasingly being forced to treat
higher and higher volumes of pediatric patients to
maintain incomes at the same time that the epidemiology
of childhood disease is suggesting that the real action
for serious morbidity and mortality is in treating kids
with serious chronic illness,” he said.
Dr Wise noted that some pediatricians are turning away
children with serious chronic illnesses because they
cannot take care of them. “Something is fundamentally
wrong with pediatric practice if that is going to
happen,” he added.
Dr Wise urged a rethinking of pediatric training,
saying, “Such that the trainees spend more and more time
in community settings learning how to structure
pediatric practices to provide high-quality clinical
care for that group of chronically ill kids who need it
most.”